Car enthusiasts are a pain in the butt to auto dealers

Here’s why car enthusiasts are at a big disadvantage when buying a new car
Tim Boyle/Getty Images

What kind of car buyer are you? Really, how would you describe yourself in that search for the next vehicle? The answer you give may be very telling as to how you’re treated in a dealership, says

Contrary to what you think, being a well-informed, knowledgeable car buyer doesn’t impress the salesperson. It drives them off, pardon the pun. Writer Jack Baruth, who at one time sold cars, says dealers and salespeople actually hate seeing what he terms “enthusiasts” walk in the door because they know it will end up costing them. How? He describes it this way:

“The time it will take him to deal with you—and your factory-order specs, and your determination to pay factory invoice, and your requests that your new vehicle not be washed with a brush or rag before delivery—is about three times as long as it will take him to lease a new SUV crossover. To a busy parent of three. Who will make the decision based on nothing but monthly payment.”

Baruth says car enthusiasts are like the people you make fun of at a restaurant. You know the ones. While you order the #5, your friend will order the #5 but without half the ingredients listed and then add in these extra ingredients but only on the side and make sure that it is cooked in non-gmo earth-friendly oil. Your order took 5 seconds, your friend took 5 minutes. That’s how a salesperson views a car enthusiast.

“While you’re asking him to confirm that the Track Pack is available for March production, he’s watching his fellow salespeople close deals with about 30 to 40 percent of the people who walk in, making high-profit sales that take less than 90 minutes from handshake to wave goodbye. Each one of those deals can mean well over $1000 in salesperson profit with the right incentives. Your invoice-price factory order? That’s what we call a “mini deal,” which pays between 50 and 500 bucks.”

To get the best deal AND the service you expect, Baruth suggests making an appointment to meet with a salesperson during a weekday before 4 p.m. Stay away from weekends altogether. Come in armed with knowledge and flexibility. And be willing to put something on the table.

“Thanks for making time for me today. I’m interested in ordering a new Gorgonzola MVS-400istxC Black Edition to my specs. I’m not in a hurry. However, if the numbers are right, I will give you a deposit today and I will place my order today.”

By keeping “today” high in the conversation, Baruth says you dramatically increase your chance to have a good experience and get exactly the car you want.

Check Also

Toyota wins 2018 24 Hours of Le Mans after so many years of heartbreak

After more than a decade of heart-crushing defeats, Toyota finally won the historic 24 Hours of Le Mans on Sunday, claiming both the overall win and the LMP1 class. Piloting the number No. 8 Toyota TS050 Hybrid were Sébastien Buemi, Kazuki Nakajima, and Fernando Alonso, with Nakajima behind the wheel at the end of the race. The No. 8 car started the...

New hypercar class announced for 2021 LeMans

Come 2021, the 24 Hours of Le Mans will look very different. The FIA announced on Friday new regulations for the motorsport to include a "hypercar" class in the World Endurance Championship for the years 2020-2024. "The new regulations for the FIA World Endurance Championship, which come into effect for the 2020/2021 season, are the result of hard work...